irclog2html for #htc-linux on 20070131

00:03.02*** join/#htc-linux lilliput (n=Touriste@82-47-146-8.cable.ubr11.brad.blueyonder.co.uk)
00:14.42*** join/#htc-linux Niacin (n=Niacin@cpe-76-187-29-166.tx.res.rr.com)
01:02.44*** join/#htc-linux Hawk|- (n=Hawk@p57A50F36.dip0.t-ipconnect.de)
02:45.45*** join/#htc-linux Zule (n=Zule@24-155-75-206.dyn.grandenetworks.net)
03:17.09*** join/#htc-linux daxxar_ (i=daxxar@daxxar.com)
05:13.17*** join/#htc-linux rmoravcik (n=rmoravci@pc-3s0zt5w2e4y0vzmhnrzq3a21zqajzfw.users.student.utc.sk)
07:35.38*** join/#htc-linux lilliput (n=Touriste@82-47-146-8.cable.ubr11.brad.blueyonder.co.uk)
07:37.30*** join/#htc-linux rob_w (n=rob_w@p549B8A68.dip0.t-ipconnect.de)
08:12.14*** join/#htc-linux rob_w (n=rob_w@p549B8A68.dip0.t-ipconnect.de)
08:21.17*** join/#htc-linux Fossi (n=cmewes@195.177.48.115)
08:58.53*** join/#htc-linux pH5 (n=ph5@e178211051.adsl.alicedsl.de)
09:09.04*** join/#htc-linux pH5 (n=ph5@e178211051.adsl.alicedsl.de)
09:43.13*** join/#htc-linux tudenbart (n=willi@xdsl-81-173-168-251.netcologne.de)
10:22.44*** join/#htc-linux pH5_ (n=ph5@e178254120.adsl.alicedsl.de)
10:51.42*** join/#htc-linux LunohoD (n=alex@e180109229.adsl.alicedsl.de)
11:27.54*** join/#htc-linux goxboxlive (n=goxboxli@195.159.97.196)
11:28.29gxl|workcr2: Are you around?
12:13.13*** part/#htc-linux g3gg0__ (n=g3gg0@ppp-62-245-211-13.dynamic.mnet-online.de)
12:22.48*** join/#htc-linux crashmatrix (n=quakepro@s5590785f.adsl.wanadoo.nl)
13:40.07*** join/#htc-linux Fossi (n=cmewes@195.177.48.115)
13:45.29cr2hi gxl|work
14:15.04*** join/#htc-linux silven (n=zmc@69.89.36.38)
14:18.20*** join/#htc-linux cyrill62 (n=cyrill62@ble59-5-82-233-205-36.fbx.proxad.net)
14:33.09gxl|workhi cr2, are you still here?
15:10.14*** join/#htc-linux Foxdie (i=Foxdie@62-30-53-72.cable.ubr02.harb.blueyonder.co.uk)
15:18.38*** join/#htc-linux lama (n=lama@estel.wpia.uw.edu.pl)
15:39.39*** join/#htc-linux shido6 (n=shido6@d221-68-200.commercial.cgocable.net)
15:56.20rob_whmm i get CMS error 38 when i try to send sms .. any ideas ??
15:56.36rob_w38 is "Network out of order " but from my other phone it works great
16:08.35*** join/#htc-linux pleemans (n=peter@d51A5E76A.access.telenet.be)
17:00.49*** join/#htc-linux goxboxlive (n=goxboxli@9.80-202-160.nextgentel.com)
17:22.56*** join/#htc-linux WizMaui (n=WizMaui@62.112.90.231)
17:23.10*** part/#htc-linux WizMaui (n=WizMaui@62.112.90.231)
17:26.54*** join/#htc-linux WizMaui (n=WizMaui@62.112.90.231)
17:40.02*** join/#htc-linux cyrill62 (n=cyrill62@ble59-5-82-233-205-36.fbx.proxad.net)
17:42.39*** join/#htc-linux renatostore (n=renato4@72-181-119-85.dyn4.digitaleitalia.it)
17:44.49*** join/#htc-linux pwr (n=pwr@86.121.146.46)
17:45.16*** join/#htc-linux WizMaui (n=WizMaui@62.112.90.231)
17:58.40*** join/#htc-linux lilliput (n=Touriste@82-47-146-8.cable.ubr11.brad.blueyonder.co.uk)
18:15.07*** join/#htc-linux rejon (n=rejon@c-24-23-175-209.hsd1.mn.comcast.net)
18:17.33*** part/#htc-linux rejon (n=rejon@c-24-23-175-209.hsd1.mn.comcast.net)
18:19.26*** join/#htc-linux cyrill62 (n=cyrill62@ble59-5-82-233-205-36.fbx.proxad.net)
18:27.08renatostorehi all
18:27.44renatostorei'd like start using linux on my alpine
18:28.13renatostorebut i miss phone and battery (suspend)
18:28.32renatostoreanyone can help?
18:33.58*** join/#htc-linux goxboxlive (n=goxboxli@9.80-202-160.nextgentel.com)
18:35.47*** join/#htc-linux goxboxlive (n=goxboxli@9.80-202-160.nextgentel.com)
18:39.18*** join/#htc-linux DD (i=DD@89-212-41-157.static.dsl.t-2.net)
18:40.30DDhi... i am tracking porting to htc blueangel for quite a while but i have no idea (http://www.handhelds.org/moin/moin.cgi/BlueAngel) is it allready usefull to normal user or not, can someone enlighten me?
18:41.50*** join/#htc-linux lilliput (n=Touriste@82-47-146-8.cable.ubr11.brad.blueyonder.co.uk)
18:57.26*** join/#htc-linux Tjikkun (n=tjikkun@82-204-54-115.dsl.bbeyond.nl)
18:59.10*** join/#htc-linux lilliput (n=Touriste@82-47-146-8.cable.ubr11.brad.blueyonder.co.uk)
19:09.58pH5renatostore: about the phone driver, I'll wait for the openmoko code to be released before continuing with that. for now you could just copy the magician driver and replace gsm_init with the method I told you.
19:10.25*** join/#htc-linux WizMaui (n=WizMaui@62.112.90.231)
19:11.17pH5for battery we need to identify the (e)gpios used to control the ds1wm chip.
19:11.31renatostoreph5: let's work on phone
19:11.35renatostorenow
19:12.23renatostorewhich is the name of the module source to rename?
19:12.24pH5magician_phone.c in arch/arm/mach-pxa/magician
19:12.25*** part/#htc-linux WizMaui (n=WizMaui@62.112.90.231)
19:13.28pH5move it to htcalpine/alpine_phone.c or something like that and add it to Makefile/Kconfig
19:14.34renatostorehow?
19:15.01renatostoretyping makefile?
19:15.46renatostorei think that the best thing is to include it in cvs
19:16.01renatostorebut i don't know how
19:18.12pH5you can send patches to kernel-discuss@handhelds.org
19:20.08renatostoreok so, if i understand, i can work to have a local module working and after i have to send patch to kernel-discuss@handheld.org
19:21.06pH5renatostore: correct. I don't think it is a good idea to put too much non-working code into cvs
19:21.41renatostorewhy non-working ... I can test before
19:22.09pH5exactly, that is the way we should do it.
19:22.28renatostoreok i agree ... what about makefile
19:23.03renatostorei rename the source
19:23.29renatostorebut how to include in makefile?
19:23.44pH5look at magician/Makefile and  magician/Kconfig to compare
19:23.52pH5obj-$(CONFIG_MAGICIAN_PHONE)            += magician_phone.o
19:24.12pH5is in the Makefile
19:24.16pH5so you could add
19:24.17pH5obj-$(CONFIG_ALPINE_PHONE)            += alpine_phone.o
19:24.45pH5in the same way you copy the MAGICIAN_PHONE section from the magician/Kconfig
19:28.44*** join/#htc-linux Ralith (n=ralith@66.150.12.86)
19:30.17renatostorei did
19:31.02renatostorewhat to modify in source
19:33.50pH5remove the contents of magician_gsm_reset and magician_gsm_off and comment out the GPCR(11) stuff in magician_phone_configure
19:34.20pH5in magician_phone_init remove the machine_is_magician test (because yours is not :)) or replace it with a machine_is_htcalpine
19:34.39pH5and then put what I told you last time in the gsm_reset function
19:35.18renatostore"remove the contents" means all function or only body
19:36.47renatostorepls give me again the address
19:36.57renatostoreof modifications
19:38.01pH5just the body. gsm_off will be empty for now (no, leave the printk in there).
19:38.41pH5oh, we had those CPLD and ASIC5 accesses. looks like we'll need a little more code
19:39.30*** join/#htc-linux BabelO (n=Fabrice@lun34-2-82-238-28-28.fbx.proxad.net)
19:43.48pH5renatostore: http://en.pastebin.ca/334645
19:43.59pH5let's see, perhaps we can live without the asic5 initialization for now
19:48.01*** join/#htc-linux Funklord (n=cow@c-cbd572d5.014-46-73746f28.cust.bredbandsbolaget.se)
19:50.32renatostorei'm not sure what i'm doing ... pls can you post the whole alpine_phone.c ?
19:57.47pH5renatostore: sorry, I don't have it. If you can't get it to work, I'll make one later.
20:06.01renatostoredo you have the magician_phone ?
20:06.17renatostore.c
20:07.26renatostorewhat do you miss?
20:10.19pH5it doesn't wake up reliably from sleep on incoming calls, wakeup from bluetooth doesn't work, I miss recording sound and battery/led handling while the device is suspended.
20:10.27pH5and of course a whole load of cleanups
20:10.48pH5and sdio :)
20:11.49pH5also I didn't GPRS to work, but I hope I can learn something from the neo1973 driver once it gets out.
20:12.03pH5s/didn't GPRS/didn't get GPRS/
20:28.01*** join/#htc-linux moebius- (i=DD@89-212-41-157.static.dsl.t-2.net)
20:39.42renatostoreph5: i copied all content of en.pastebin.ca/334645 into magician_gsm_reset. Is it correst?
20:49.35pH5ah no. just the contents of alpine_gsm_reset. the others are helper functions, put them above the _gsm_reset function (they should be in their own drivers, actually. one for the cpld and one for asic5)
20:54.41renatostorei also see include /arch/magician.h
20:55.02renatostoreshould i change it?
20:55.17pH5drop that, and magician_cpld.h as well.
20:56.31*** join/#htc-linux ekkobelli (n=michi@p54A3D437.dip.t-dialin.net)
20:56.40*** part/#htc-linux ekkobelli (n=michi@p54A3D437.dip.t-dialin.net)
20:56.59renatostorecan i search & change "magician" with "alpine" ?
21:01.15pH5sure :)
21:04.39renatostorefor example:
21:04.41renatostoreextern struct platform_device magician_cpld;
21:04.44renatostorebecame
21:04.51renatostoreextern struct platform_device alpine
21:04.59renatostore_cpld
21:05.00renatostore;
21:07.33pH5actually the magician_cpld is magician specific, remove it
21:07.47pH5(the magician_egpio_.. calls that need it are gone)
21:10.13renatostorei think that it is better if you can rewrite the source and i will compile and test it
21:10.45*** join/#htc-linux goxboxlive (n=goxboxli@9.80-202-160.nextgentel.com)
21:12.04pH5maybe you're right
21:43.17*** join/#htc-linux goxboxlive (n=goxboxli@9.80-202-160.nextgentel.com)
21:48.06*** join/#htc-linux pwr (n=pwr@86.121.146.46)
21:57.43goxboxlivecr2: Are you awake?
21:58.14goxboxlivehi BabelO: Any Qtopia news?
21:58.15*** join/#htc-linux tudenbart (n=willi@xdsl-81-173-169-103.netcologne.de)
21:58.25BabelOhi goxboxlive
21:59.05BabelOno, lot of works these days, start of the year :)
21:59.48BabelOi m looking at sound for BA but can't compile  2.6.19 with sound :(
22:00.26goxboxliveright, i havent done anything my self. I just wouldnt configure anymore with TSLIB enabled. It's strange, because iu havent touched the content in the include and libs directories
22:00.36goxboxlivei c
22:00.36lamaBabelO: Blue Angel?
22:00.44BabelOlama: yes
22:00.52lamaoh, cool
22:00.57pH5BabelO: what is the issue?
22:00.59goxboxliveSO you BA hasent had any sound since .12 right?
22:01.11lamaI'm thinking about buying phone with qwerty
22:01.44lamaBA looks quite good on paper
22:01.47BabelOgoxboxlive: yes, lkc have done lot of research work, so we have all data to do driver and magician as base
22:01.53lamagprs only is main drawback
22:02.09goxboxlivei c
22:02.35goxboxliveright, it's getting late. night all
22:02.46BabelOlama: it is an old phone now :(
22:02.53pH5'night goxboxlive
22:03.02BabelOhi pH5
22:03.06lamaBabelO: yes, but has 128mb of RAM ;]
22:03.23lamahow good is keyboard compared to Wizard
22:03.33BabelOlama: yes, under linux we have 96 Mo of free ram :)
22:03.51lamaonly 96?
22:04.08lamawhat takes so much RAM ?
22:04.53BabelOlama: i have a lot of filesystem cache
22:05.55pH5hi BabelO. cr2 mentioned the GSM chip of the openmoko/neo1973 phone will be the same as in blueangel/alpine/magician.
22:06.01pH5does GPRS work on the ba?
22:06.36lamaBabelO: how fast is firefox on it?
22:06.44BabelOpH5: yes, i read the log :) no GPRS working with dpram driver ... but it work before with 2.6.12 kernel
22:07.57BabelOlama: i only test mozilla on BA under wince and it is too slow, and opera speed is good,
22:08.25lamaBabelO: mini or mobile opera?
22:08.52BabelOmini is for MIDP right ? so i think i test mobile for Qtek
22:09.00lamaBabelO: I know that minimo is slow, but I was hoping that 128mb of ram and 400Mhz CPU could be better
22:09.27lamaBabelO: right mini is j2me midp 1 and 2
22:09.35lamabut mini might be better for gprs
22:09.50lamait uses proxy with compression and "prerendering"
22:10.27BabelOlama: ok :) i use opera with Wifi to connect to ogame.fr :) my favorite online game :)
22:10.35lamahaha
22:11.05lamaBabelO: how far is Linux port from usable status?
22:11.15BabelOOpera is the only one i found that can run easily javascript...
22:11.39lamaI've seen booting on youtube, quite long...
22:12.46BabelOlinux port on 2.6.12 kernel is ok, but without wifi and camera... and there is suspend problem
22:13.19lamawhat with "phone module", is it possible to use voice calling ?
22:13.46BabelOi m working with asymuled on 2.6.19 port and lkcl help us with sound support
22:14.07BabelOlama : with 2.6.12 it works
22:14.25BabelOyou have a gpe image with gommunicator app that is phone app
22:15.47lamaBabelO: cool
22:16.00lamawhat is "suspend issue"
22:16.23lamaor how long it can survive with running linux? ;]
22:17.46BabelOlama: i did n't test it enought with 2.6.12, but in suspend mode, LCD power is always on
22:18.22lamaBabelO: are you using it as a phone or just as a "linux toy" ?
22:19.52BabelOlama i use ba as a windows phone for moment, and linux on futur if i can have a working opie phone application and sound driver
22:20.17lamaWIZARD, HERMES, ETEN M700 thats are phone I've been looking at first, but since I know that BA boots linux I'm not so sure now
22:20.33lamaBabelO: yeah, opie is better than gpe, faster...
22:20.49lamaBabelO: what are main drawbacks for you with this phone?
22:22.01lamaI wonder how good is this keyboard, and how big this phone is reality, I've seen dimension values, and various pictures, but it doesn't tell how big it is "in real usage"
22:22.27BabelOlama : for me it is battery life
22:23.01cr2lama: i'm not excited by ba keyboard
22:23.21BabelOdo you know sony clie palm ? size is the same
22:23.31BabelOhi cr2
22:23.33cr2it's more difficult to use even than the old sl5500 zaurus.
22:23.36cr2hi BabelO
22:23.46BabelOyes i never use BA keyboard
22:23.50cr2but i'm spoiled by the universal :)
22:24.13cr2and by hermes, but universal is better.
22:24.19pH5hey cr2. how does the universal keyboard compare to the hermes'? (apart from the obvious size issue)..
22:24.25pH5.. was what  I just  wanted to ask :)
22:25.12cr2pH5: it's the best what you can do in a magician formfactor.
22:25.17cr2i think it's ok.
22:25.41cr2pH5: harald posted the moko AT command list.
22:25.51cr2lama: jornada820 is still better :)
22:26.03cr2but it's a notebook.
22:26.22lamabtw, how can you use screen, vi etc programs with ssh on keyboards without ctrl, esc, etc. ?
22:26.41lamaI know it's possible to remap keys, or use sip, but isn't it painful in use?
22:26.49cr2pH5: i can see some weird commands. do you have a full list from the decoded radio ?
22:26.58lamacr2: I can fit jornada into jacket pocket
22:27.53cr2lama: and the half-vga screen ? i like the pcmcia slot though.
22:28.22lamayes, 640x240, pcmcia, CF, wince, linux, netbsd ;]
22:28.48cr2i have found a 16bit pcmcia wifi card from t-mob. can't make it to work with linux :(
22:28.50pH5cr2: yes. is it on the moko-dev list?
22:28.59cr2pH5: yes.
22:29.10cr2look in the archives, if it#s there.
22:29.22cr2:D
22:29.42lamacr2: well you shouldn't look for anything else than hermes or prism2.5 chipset based
22:30.34cr2lama: i think the m$ driver uploads some firmware in motorola hex.
22:30.49cr2looks like some prism stuff.
22:31.50cr2but the prism driver alone does not detect anything, even if i add the pcmcia ids in the source.
22:32.09pH5cr2: the list is archived only since jan2007..
22:32.24cr2pH5: it was yesterday.
22:32.57cr2AT commands (Re: But wich GSM chip? Re: AT commands document (Was: Fax modem? Fax software? Neo as T.38 gateway?))
22:33.28cr2i can send it to you. if i'll find your e-mail.
22:33.39cr2or i can pastebin it.
22:33.42pH5ah, I found it. on the community list
22:35.47cr2ok.
22:36.08pH5cr2: you were talking about some of the AT% commands?
22:36.31cr2yes.
22:36.54lamaBabelO: do you think universal is better phone?
22:37.07lamaboth are on the big side for me
22:37.24pH5cr2: I'm sure I don't have things like %EFRSLT in my radio rom..
22:37.30lamabut linux is a plus
22:38.03pH5there seem to be a lot of AT+ commands duplicated with AT% counterparts
22:38.18lamafor me universal is too similar in shape to jornada, I would like something like Wizard with linux, and VGA screen ;]
22:38.38lamaSharp w3 zero has VGA and Xscale
22:39.26BabelOlama: universal is better, but buy a nice bluetooth headset before :)
22:39.41cr2pH5: *FR* sound like FilterResponse to me.
22:40.33lamaBabelO: haha
22:40.46lamaI won't buy it, it's too big, even BA looks big for me
22:40.48cr2lama: sharp VGA LCD is bigger than universal's -> worse dpi. and it has no umts and 2 cams of course
22:41.16lamacr2: yeah, but universal is huge ;]
22:41.20cr2true.
22:41.41cr2heh. and sharp does not have wifi.
22:41.50lamathe only hot point is linux in my opinion ;]
22:42.05lamacr2: and afaik sharp is available in asia only
22:42.32cr2in bizarre form from lineo. good that it was rewritten.
22:44.06cr2"commercial linux" code from lineo/motorola looks like windows code ;)
22:44.42BabelOcr2: i m agree with you lineo code is really strange
22:44.52lamahuh, do you mean that sharp runs linux?
22:45.18lamaI was talking about linux beeing hot point of universal ;]
22:48.03cr2imho, hima/ba/universal have very good hw design.
22:48.13cr2good for linux :)
22:48.29cr2i don't know anything comparable.
22:48.53cr2look at sharp to know what i mean.
22:49.00BabelOcr2: how far is samsung linux port ?
22:49.51cr2BabelO: i need to add the early fb debug patches to move forward, but have not find time ;)
22:50.42BabelOcr2: ok, i m thinking about buying htc tyn
22:51.25lamaBabelO: tyn doesn't have jack! usb phones sux
22:51.59lamaeten m700 looks better, almost perfect but it doesn't have umts...
22:52.27cr2lama: and gps
22:52.30BabelOlama: i know, but it have maybe a gps builtin or looking at eten glowfish
22:52.35cr2BabelO: tytn is hermes
22:52.43lamaand do not have j2me midp enviroment in ROM
22:52.57cr2lama: java ...
22:53.28BabelOcr2: yes without keyboard :)
22:53.32lamaand I've seen TCPMP benchmarks and it was really slow compared to HERMES/TynTyn... strange, I bet it's first ROM issue
22:53.49cr2lama: it's the ati 2d accel issue.
22:54.06cr2do you know the eten m700 internals ?
22:54.24lamano
22:54.30cr2that's why i like hima/ba vs. universal.
22:54.51lamaTynTyn is samsnung CPU too
22:55.00cr2because hima/ba has ati 2d accel  chip. pxa27x framebuffer sucks.
22:55.38cr2lama: the video on tytn does not use s3c2442 lcd.
23:00.28pH5just a little bit too thick and too expensive, unfortunately
23:00.32pH5good night
23:00.34lamawizard and eten m700 have similar
23:06.59cr2lama: can you describe eten m700 hardware ?
23:07.26cr2we know herme very well.
23:12.01lamainternals?
23:12.08lamaor just specs? ;]
23:13.28lamahttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r9Z8Z1jR7hI here is youtube pr0n with eten m700 ;]
23:14.11lamaeten is said to release first 3g phone this year;]
23:15.12lamamight be perfect, but I'm sure they will fsck up something from eten m700 like HTC done it with "upgrade from Wizard to Hermes ;]
23:17.46BabelOcr2:  Samsung S3C 2440 + Wifi b/g +bluetooth 2.0 +FM radio + GPS sirf III and battery capacity same as BA :(
23:20.07lamahttp://smartmania.mobilmania.cz/index.php?ind=reviews&op=entry_view&iden=160
23:20.33lamaczech review ;]
23:20.56lamabut pictures and TCPMP benchmarks are in english hahaha
23:22.40cr2the keyboard looks like hermes.
23:22.45BabelOcr2: EDR for bluetooth in the eten M700
23:23.29Hymiebaha.. lama, I saw this pic: http://smartmania.mobilmania.cz/images/recenze/EtenM700/29.jpg .. and thought some really wild PDA was underfoot
23:23.50cr2(-) price ?
23:24.04lamaabout 600$ in USA
23:24.06BabelOcr2: 699 EUROS :(
23:24.37HymieE-Ten M700 se v \u010ceské republice za\u010dne prodávat v lednu 2007 za cenu 18499,- K\u010d. Pokud se m\u011b chcete na cokoliv ohledn\u011b tohoto za\u0159ízení zeptat, máte mo\u017enost v na\u0161em diskuzním fóru nebo v komentá\u0159ích pod recenzí. Spoustu dal\u0161ích fotografií naleznete v Galerii
23:24.38lamaHymie: that is real PDA pr0n! ;]
23:24.43Hymielama: heh
23:25.38lamaonly wizard and BA are in my price range now
23:26.49lamaI can find more cash for universal, hermes or eten, but I don't think this devices are worth so much, all lacks soemthing important from my point of view
23:27.00cr2the +universal photo is lame.
23:27.08cr2it does not show anything.
23:28.25BabelOgood night all
23:50.04*** join/#htc-linux WizMaui (n=WizMaui@62.112.90.231)

Generated by irclog2html.pl by Jeff Waugh - find it at freshmeat.net! Modified by Tim Riker to work with blootbot logs, split per channel, etc.